Why does a file input let through files you did not ask for?
You set accept=".pdf", a visitor sends a photo, and your inbox gets something you cannot open. That is not a bug in your form. Every attribute on a file input is advice to the browser's picker. None of them inspects the file, and a file that reaches the input some other way skips the picker entirely.
To see how far that goes, on 3 November 2026 we handed real files from disk to file inputs in the three browser engines that matter: Chromium (Chrome, Edge), Firefox and WebKit (Safari). Then we posted them to a local copy of Formgong's form backend to see what a server gets. This page covers the input element itself. The whole upload setup, from storage to email links, is in our guide to the contact form with file upload.
What do accept, multiple and capture do?
Here are the three inputs most forms need. The labels matter: a file input's button text comes from the browser, so the label is the only place to say what you want and how big it may be. Our accessible contact form checklist starts with a visible label for every field.
<!-- One PDF, required --> <label for="cv">Your CV (PDF, up to 5 MB)</label> <input id="cv" name="cv" type="file" accept=".pdf,application/pdf" required> <!-- Several photos --> <label for="photos">Photos of the damage</label> <input id="photos" name="photos" type="file" accept="image/*" multiple> <!-- On a phone, open the back camera straight away --> <label for="snap">Take a photo of the receipt</label> <input id="snap" name="receipt" type="file" accept="image/*" capture="environment">
How strict is each attribute?
accept takes extensions (.pdf), exact types (application/pdf) or a family (image/*). List both the extension and the type, because some systems match one and some the other. The picker uses it to grey out other files. Files that reach the input another way are not filtered: our test tool put a .csv, an .HEIC and a file with no extension into an input with accept=".pdf,application/pdf", and all three engines took them.
multiple is a plain on or off switch. In our test all three engines held 3 of 3 files in the input's files list. There is no attribute for a maximum count, so a limit of three is something your script and your server enforce.
capture="environment" asks for the back camera and capture="user" for the front one. It only does something on phones. None of the three desktop engines we ran exposes it as a property; they keep the attribute in the HTML and do nothing with it. We did not test a phone, so treat camera behaviour as unverified here and try it on the devices your visitors use.
Can the browser tell what kind of file it is?
No. The browser fills file.type from the file name, not from the bytes. That is why a type check in JavaScript does not stop a renamed file:
| File | Chromium | Firefox | WebKit |
|---|---|---|---|
A real PDF, cv-oliver-bennett.pdf | application/pdf | application/pdf | application/pdf |
A GIF renamed holiday.pdf | application/pdf | application/pdf | application/pdf |
An iPhone photo name, IMG_0042.HEIC | (empty) | image/heic | image/heif |
orders.csv | text/csv | text/csv | text/csv |
README, no extension | (empty) | (empty) | (empty) |
The renamed GIF was a PDF to every engine. The iPhone photo got three different answers, and Chromium gave none. If you filter by file.type in the browser, an HEIC photo from an iPhone can fail in Chrome and pass in Safari. Filter by extension if you must filter in the browser, and leave the real decision to the server.
How do you check the file size before upload?
There is no max-size attribute. Read file.size (in bytes) when the visitor picks a file and set a custom validity message. That way the browser's own form checks block the submit and show your text, the same way they do for an empty required field.
In our test a 6 MiB PDF made reportValidity() return false in 3 of 3 engines, and each showed the message from the script. Use the same limit as your server, so the visitor hears about it before a long upload instead of after it.
<script>
var MAX_BYTES = 5 * 1024 * 1024; // 5 MB, the same limit as your server
document.getElementById("cv").addEventListener("change", function (event) {
var input = event.target;
var file = input.files[0];
// An empty message means "valid"; any text blocks the submit and is shown by the browser.
input.setCustomValidity(file && file.size > MAX_BYTES ? "This file is over 5 MB. Please pick a smaller one." : "");
});
</script>Why does the value say C:\fakepath?
Read input.value after picking a file and you get C:\fakepath\cv-oliver-bennett.pdf, even on Linux and macOS. We saw exactly that string in all three engines. Browsers hide the real folder to keep your file system private, and the fake prefix is a leftover kept so old scripts do not break. Use input.files[0].name when you want the name.
Two more things trip people up. files is read-only, so you cannot splice one file out of it; you build a new list. And setting value to an empty string is the one change you may make to the value, which clears the input. In our run, removing the second of three files left a.png,c.png and clearing left 0 files, in every engine.
// FileList is read-only. To drop one file, build a new list without it.
function removeFile(input, index) {
var list = new DataTransfer();
Array.from(input.files).forEach(function (file, i) { if (i !== index) list.items.add(file); });
input.files = list.files;
}
// To clear the input completely:
input.value = "";What happens if the form has no enctype?
The form looks like it works and the file never arrives. Without enctype="multipart/form-data" the browser sends the form as URL-encoded text, and a file input in that format contributes only its file name. We tried both versions against our local backend with the same PDF:
| What we sent | What the server did |
|---|---|
No enctype, a PDF picked | Stored as text: "attachment": "cv-oliver-bennett.pdf", no file |
enctype="multipart/form-data", the same PDF | Stored: the message plus a 125-byte PDF |
A GIF renamed holiday.pdf | 415 file_type: "Only genuine PDF, JPEG and PNG files are accepted." |
| Four PDFs in one post | 413 too_large |
| A 6 MiB PDF | 413 too_large |
| A PDF to a form with attachments off | 400 uploads_disabled |
The first row is the classic silent failure: no error anywhere, a submission in the inbox, and a file name where the file should be. With fetch you avoid it by passing new FormData(form) as the body and leaving the Content-Type header alone, so the browser can add the multipart boundary. How the parts look on the wire is in how HTML forms work at a low level.
How do you send the file to a form backend?
Point the form at a backend that stores files, keep the method POST and the enctype multipart. With Formgong that is the form below. Turn on attachments in the form settings and add Cloudflare Turnstile, because a post with a file always needs a solved Turnstile check there, even on forms that do not ask for one on text. The settings are in the HTML form docs.
Formgong takes PDF, PNG and JPEG, up to 3 files, 5 MiB each and 10 MiB together in a plain form post. If you need the file to land somewhere else as well, the webhook docs show the attachment links the payload carries.
<form action="https://formgong.com/submit" method="POST" enctype="multipart/form-data"> <input type="hidden" name="access_key" value="fk_your_access_key"> <label for="name">Name</label> <input id="name" name="name" autocomplete="name" required> <label for="cv">Your CV (PDF, up to 5 MB)</label> <input id="cv" name="cv" type="file" accept=".pdf,application/pdf" required> <div class="cf-turnstile" data-sitekey="YOUR_TURNSTILE_SITE_KEY"></div> <button type="submit">Send</button> </form> <script src="https://challenges.cloudflare.com/turnstile/v0/api.js" async defer></script>
Where does Formgong check more than other form backends?
On the server, Formgong checks three things before it keeps a file: the extension, the type the browser claimed, and the first and last bytes of the file itself. That is how the renamed GIF above came back as file_type while every browser had called it a PDF. Formspree's guide to the HTML file input tells readers to validate types and sizes on the server, but it does not say what Formspree itself checks. The Static Forms article on accept, dated 20 October 2026, says its own documentation states the service does not enforce file-type validation. Both pages were read on 3 November 2026. The other side of the trade is that Formgong accepts only three file types, so a form that needs Word documents or ZIP files is better served elsewhere.
Did a file input behave differently for you?
If a phone opened the wrong camera, or a browser we did not test reported a different type, write to support@formgong.com with the device and the file name. We will add it to the table, with your permission.
Frequently asked questions
Does the accept attribute stop other file types?
No. It only filters the picker. Files that reach the input another way are not filtered, and a renamed file passes by its name. Check the file on the server.
How do I limit file size in an HTML file input?
There is no attribute for it. Read file.size in a change listener and call setCustomValidity with a message when the file is too big, then check again on the server.
What does capture do on a file input?
On phones it asks for the camera: environment for the back camera, user for the front. In our test none of three desktop browser engines supported it.
Why is the file missing from my form submission?
Usually the form has no enctype="multipart/form-data". Without it the browser sends only the file name. With fetch, pass FormData and do not set Content-Type.
Sources and documentation
Official references for this guide: Formgong: Contact form with file upload, Formgong: How HTML forms work at a low level. HTML forms, where data is stored.
Related guides
- Lovable form submissions to email and Telegram
- HTML contact form without a backend: a working example
- How to send website form submissions to Telegram
- Contact form not sending email? Check where it stops
- Managing website leads in Telegram without a CRM
- Form backend for Lovable, Bolt, v0, Cursor
- Telegram bot for a contact form: build or skip?
- GDPR form backend: 7 checks before you choose
- Lovable form not sending email? 6 fixes
- Netlify Forms not working? React and Bolt fixes
- Stop contact form spam without a CAPTCHA
- GitHub Pages contact form: a working setup
- Mailto Form in HTML: Why It Fails and What to Use
- HTML form to Google Sheets: 2 free methods
- Webflow form submission limit: what to do at 50
- Turnstile vs reCAPTCHA vs hCaptcha for forms
- Contact Form 7 and Elementor forms to Telegram
- Squarespace contact form not sending email?
- Shopify contact form: where do messages go?
- Google Form to Telegram: free Apps Script way
- Wix contact form not sending email? Fixes
- EU / GDPR Formspree alternatives compared
- HTML form action attribute explained
- How do HTML forms work? The HTTP request
- Types of Injection Attacks on Web Forms (2026)
- Indirect Prompt Injection in MCP
- MCP Rug Pull Attack: Detect Tool Changes
- Form without a backend: 7 ways that work
- Thank-you page after form submission (HTML)
- Indirect Prompt Injection Examples (2023–2026)
- Indirect Prompt Injection via Email
- What Is Tool Poisoning in MCP?
- WordPress contact form without a plugin
- Send email from frontend JavaScript
- How to Prevent Indirect Prompt Injection
- Honeypot Form Field: How to Add One That Works
- Contact Form with File Upload (HTML, No PHP)
- Angular contact form without a backend
- Send form submissions to Slack or Discord without Zapier
- Verify a form webhook signature (HMAC-SHA256)
- Contact forms that send nothing: 793 AI-built sites tested
- v0 contact form that actually sends: 3 ways
- How we tested AI-built contact forms, and 12 bugs we hit
- Cloudflare vs Netlify free plan: hosting that never pauses
- EmailJS 412 “Gmail_API: Invalid grant”: reconnect Gmail
- Resend “You can only send testing emails”: verify a domain
- Supabase Edge Function blocked by CORS policy: 3 causes
- Formspree “Form not found” and other errors: fixes
- Web3Forms errors: “Invalid access key” and 403 explained
- How to add customer reviews to your website for free
- Getform not working? “This form has been deleted” and more
- Next.js contact form not working? 6 errors, reproduced
- Webflow form not sending email? What to check, tested
- FormSubmit not working? “This form needs Activation” fix
- Contact form “TypeError: Failed to fetch”: causes and fixes
- WooCommerce product enquiry form
- Contact Form 7 vs WPForms
- Gravity Forms alternative free
- WordPress contact form block
- 535-5.7.8 Username and Password not accepted (Gmail)
- 535 5.7.3 Authentication unsuccessful: Office 365 SMTP
- Nodemailer “Missing credentials for "PLAIN"”: the fix
- Nodemailer “Greeting never received”: port 465 fix
- Nodemailer SSL “wrong version number”: the port fix
- Nodemailer “self-signed certificate in certificate chain”
- Nodemailer ECONNREFUSED 127.0.0.1:587: missing SMTP host
- SendGrid “authorization grant is invalid”: 401 fix
- Mailgun 401 Forbidden: why the API rejects your key
- “Edge Function returned a non-2xx status code”: the fix
- Next.js “Body exceeded 1 MB limit”: Server Action fix
- Unexpected token '<', "<!DOCTYPE "... is not valid JSON
- “TypeError: Body is unusable”: body has already been read
- Turnstile “timeout-or-duplicate” and other siteverify errors
- Turnstile vs hCaptcha vs reCAPTCHA: speed and size tested
- Judge.me reviews not showing on Shopify: how to fix it
- Judge.me review carousel not showing: how to fix it
- Yotpo reviews not showing on Shopify? Check the app embed
- Loox reviews not showing on product page: how to fix
- Shopify reviews not showing: what to check first
- How to show reviews on Shopify
- GDPR for website forms: what each type of form needs
- WooCommerce reviews not showing: how to fix it
- Stamped.io reviews not showing on Shopify: how to fix it
- Etsy reviews not showing: why and what to do
- Trustpilot widget not loading: how to fix TrustBox
- Yotpo problems in 2026: what merchants report
- Contact Form 7 “error trying to send your message” fix
- Elementor form “Your submission failed because of an error”
- Framer form not sending email or not working: what to check
- Carrd contact form not working: plans, spam and errors
- Google review link not working: what customers see and why
- tawk.to widget not showing on your website: causes and fixes
- How to add questions and answers to your product page
- “Failed to send a request to the Edge Function”: fixes
- Next.js “Failed to find Server Action”: what it means
- Brevo “unauthorized: Key not found” 401: the fix
- Amazon SES “Email address is not verified”: the fix
- Shopify contact form not working: how to fix it
- Judge.me alternative for WooCommerce after the 2025 shutdown
- Free WooCommerce review plugins compared on the free version
- WooCommerce review reminder emails without a paid plugin
- Add Voice Recording to a Website Form
- Contact Form 7 spam: how to stop it
- WPForms not sending email: how to fix it
- Contact form emails going to spam: how to fix it
- HTML form not submitting: how to fix it
- Contact form not working: how to find the fault
- Webflow form spam: how to stop it
- Website form to Notion: how to set it up
- Website form to WhatsApp: what works and what does not
- What 1-star reviews say about AI support chatbots
- Which free form backend gives you the most submissions?
- Elfsight reviews widget not showing? Check the view limit
- Next.js contact form backend vs Server Actions
- Review stars not showing in Google search results
- How to stop duplicate form submissions
- How to see which form leads came from ChatGPT
- What happens when a form webhook fails
- When to send a review request email after an order
- How to collect video testimonials for free
- Add contact form sign-ups to Mailchimp or Klaviyo
- How to migrate from Formspree without losing submissions
- How to get a Google review link for your business
- What is a headless form backend?
- Is it safe to put a form access key in your HTML?
- AI chatbot that answers only from your website
- Minified React error #441 in Next.js
- Squarespace product reviews after Judge.me
- Accessible contact form checklist for WCAG 2.2
- How to ask a client for a testimonial by email
- How to respond to negative reviews, with examples
- 429 Too Many Requests on a contact form
- MCP server for forms in Cursor and Claude
- Can you offer a discount for a review?
- Do EU stores have to say if reviews are verified?
- Webflow form backend options compared
- How to add review schema JSON-LD to a product page
- How to turn a customer review into an Instagram post
- How to make a QR code for Google reviews
- Live chat or chatbot for a small business website
- Why people abandon your contact form halfway
- Which form backend do AI assistants pick? 54 answers
- PHP mail() not sending email, even when it returns true
- What “Failed to fetch” means, tested in three browsers
- 405 Method Not Allowed when you submit a form
- Send a contact form to more than one email address
- What is review syndication, and who needs it?
- How to save HTML form data to a database
- NetworkError when attempting to fetch resource
- Send product reviews to Google Merchant Center
- PHPMailer not working on a live server
- AI review reply generator: does it help?
- React 19 contact form with useActionState
- Astro Actions or a form backend?
- Is no-reply@wixsiteautomations.com legit?
- Where to find the Judge.me review widget code
- AI review summaries: what shoppers actually see
- Photo reviews for WooCommerce, and the GPS inside them
- Review request email templates you can copy
- Reviews in AI search: what ChatGPT and Perplexity cite
- Lead capture form with UTM tracking, built and tested
- Form design best practices, with our own form data
- Client intake form template with file upload
- What is social proof? Meaning and examples
- What is user-generated content (UGC)?
- Benefits of negative reviews for your store
- How to get your first reviews as a new store
- How to use customer reviews in your marketing
- How to get more customer reviews
- React form validation without a library, tested
- jQuery submit form with validation
- reCAPTCHA v3 setup with the server score check
- Shopify social proof that shoppers can check
- How to add hCaptcha to a form, with the server check
- How to add invisible reCAPTCHA to a form
- Bug report form template with browser details
- What the FTC fake reviews rule bans for online stores
- How to show reviews on your homepage
- Do reviews increase sales? What the studies show
- HTML input types and what each one sends
- HTML textarea, tested in a real form
- HTML dropdown menu in a form, tested
- Do reviews help SEO? What Google says and shows
- How to add a review carousel people can read
- Product review examples that help shoppers decide
- Which trust badges actually mean something
- Customer satisfaction survey with CSAT and NPS
- JavaScript FormData and what fetch actually sends
- JavaScript form validation without a library
- Server-side form validation and what it catches
- Email validation in JavaScript, tested on 33 addresses
- Zod form validation with FormData, tested
- Store reviews vs product reviews
- How to send review requests through Klaviyo
- How to tag customer reviews by topic and mood
- Custom review form questions worth asking
- Online reputation management for small businesses
- HTML radio button groups and what they send
- HTML label tag and what screen readers hear
- HTML autocomplete attribute, tested with Chrome autofill
- HTML fieldset and legend, and what disabled leaves out
- HTML button tag and what a form button sends
- Vite contact form that still works after the build
- How to test a contact form, end to end
- How to embed a Google Form, and what it loads
- Customer feedback questions that get real answers
- How to convert a file to base64 in JavaScript
- FilePond with a form backend, and when to skip it
- Bootstrap form validation and server errors
- Tailwind form validation, tested in three browsers
- Donation form in HTML, and where the payment goes
- How to ask for a review in person or by text
- Which review sites matter for your business
- What are customer reviews, and which kinds count
- Online review statistics, checked at the source
- Best review app for Shopify and WooCommerce
- Why Gmail sends your self-hosted mail to spam
- htmx contact form that sends to another domain
- AI form builders tested, from prompt to sent form
- Headless WordPress forms with Contact Form 7, tested
- React Hook Form watch vs useWatch, and what gets sent
- Elfsight widget not working? It vanishes when views run out
- Jotform not sending emails? Check Jotform's bounce list
- Typeform not working? A white box means a blocked script
- Positive review response examples that don't sound copied
- How to remove a Google review when you can't delete it
- Google reviews not showing up? 8 causes to check in order
- Is buying Google reviews illegal? Even a review swap counts
- Which reviews can you hide? A review moderation checklist
- Average star rating: what 4.8 from 5 reviews means
- Reviews on a product page: where and how many to show
- SaaS testimonials: 3 of 27 had a number in them
- Do reviews reduce returns? Not when they're too good
- Testimonial examples for business: what makes one believable
- Testimonial questions to ask clients, by type of business
- Testimonial page design: a page or a section?
- Testimonial advertising rules: what the FTC requires
- Form submission canceled because the form is not connected
- Input type date format dd/mm/yyyy: what you can change
- How to disable textarea resize, or allow only vertical
- How to prevent Enter from submitting a form
- form.submit() vs requestSubmit(): what submit() skips
- Custom HTML checkbox CSS that doesn't break required
- How to reset a form after submit, and what reset() keeps
- Input type number maxlength not working? What to use
- How to create an HTML form, step by step
- Best form builder: free plans and branding, checked
- Best WordPress contact form plugin: 10 free ones compared
- How to increase form conversion rate: start with the count
- Form backend vs form builder: which one do you need?
- WordPress contact form not sending email? 3 plugins tested
- Contact Form 7 webhook? Turning it on switched our email off
- Gravity Forms webhook: what it sends and the URLs it rejects